Blog
Cookie Stenciling Guide: Easy Designs for Spring Treats
The Spring Rush Is Here (And We’ve Got You Covered)
Spring is one of the busiest seasons of the year for bakers. Between Easter, Mother’s Day, Teacher Appreciation, Nurse Appreciation, and Graduation, orders stack up quickly, and the turnaround time between each holiday is tight.
We know how overwhelming that can feel, especially coming off a major holiday like Easter and heading straight into another wave of demand. That’s why having easy, efficient options is so important this time of year.
Our newest spring products were designed with that in mind—to help you save time, simplify your process, and still offer beautiful, high-quality treats your customers will love. From quick decorating solutions like stencils to ready-to-go packaging, bundles, and display options, everything is created to make your workflow easier so you can stay ahead without stress.
Think of this season as the baker’s marathon, and we’re here to help you get through it with simple, smart solutions.
Easy, Consistent Designs with Stencils
We added over 20 new stencil designs for Mother’s Day, Teacher Appreciation, and Graduation—along with their matching cookie cutters—so you can create cohesive, professional-looking cookies with ease. Everything is available individually or as a set, so you can work however you prefer.
We also introduced a range of beautiful text-based stencil designs, making it easier than ever to add clean, polished wording to your cookies without the time commitment of hand lettering. No projectors, no free handing, just consistent results every time.
And for an even simpler option, we added PYO stencils that pair perfectly with our everyday PYO toppers and our PYO palettes. It’s an easy way to offer an interactive cookie that still looks intentional and elevated, without adding extra work to your process.
Below, we’ve outlined exactly how we stencil our cookies so you can get perfect results every time.
1. Set Up Your Stencil Frame
We use the Sweet Stencil Holder Plus with the frame extender for best results. If you’re new to this system, be sure to check out the tutorial video on their website before your first use, it will walk you through setup and help you get the cleanest application possible.
Start by taping your stencil to a frame extender if needed. If your cookies are thicker (around 3/8" dough and closer to 1/2" once iced), the extra height from an XL stencil holder or extender will help you get a clean, even application.
2. Use the Right Icing Consistency
Your icing should be a bit thicker than toothpaste, but not as thick as what you’d use for florals. This consistency helps prevent bleeding while still allowing for a smooth scrape. Load it into one of our tipless piping bags for easy control and application.
Note: The pink blocks shown in this tutorial are 3D printed “practice cookies” we use to test our stencils. They’re perfect for practicing and making sure your icing is the right consistency before working on real cookies. Once you’re done, simply wipe off the icing, wash them just like you would a cookie cutter, let them air dry, and they’re ready to use again and again.
Pro Tip: Perfect Placement Every Time
Place your cookie on top of a piece of white paper and trace the outline. Then slide that paper under the clear sheet of your stencil holder. This creates a guide so you can position each cookie perfectly, even when the stencil has icing on it and visibility is low. It’s a huge time saver when batching.
3. Apply Icing to the Stencil
Add a small amount of icing to the top of your stencil. Hold your scraper at a slight angle and use a light, steady, slow motion to pull the icing across the design.
4. Clean Your Scraper Between Passes
After each swipe, clean your scraper before going back over the stencil. This keeps your lines crisp and prevents excess icing from building up.
5. Lift Carefully for Clean Results
Once your design is filled, lift the stencil straight up without shifting. This helps maintain sharp edges and prevents smudging.
Cleaning Your Stencil
After use, rinse your stencil under warm water and place it somewhere like a dish rack to dry. Keeping your stencils clean will help maintain crisp designs every time.
6. Done!
Your design is ready to go! After you let it dry sufficiently (overnight for best results) your cookies are ready to package! Sit back, grab one of your test cookies to snack on, and enjoy the fruits of your labor!
Easy Packaging That Looks Like a Full Gift
You don’t need complicated packaging to make your treats feel elevated. With the right setup, even a simple cookie can look like a complete, thoughtful gift.
Our bakery boxes and treat boxes are designed to do exactly that: help you create polished, gift-ready options without adding extra time to your workflow.
Whether you’re packaging:
- Single cookies
- Small sets
- Assorted treats like brownies, cake pucks, or chocolate covered Oreos
you can quickly turn them into something that feels intentional and market-ready.
Add a few simple touches like:
…and you’ve instantly upgraded your product without adding extra labor.
This is especially helpful during the spring rush, when customers are looking for grab-and-go gifts for Mother’s Day, teachers, nurses, and graduates. The easier you make it for them, the faster your products will sell.
Keep it simple, keep it cohesive, and let your packaging do the heavy lifting.
Bundles That Take the Guesswork Out
If you’ve ever spent way too long trying to match backers, bags, and tags, you’re not alone. That’s exactly why we created our bundles.
Our bundles are designed to make your life easier by putting everything you need in one place. No second guessing sizes, no digging through multiple categories, and no worrying if everything will work together.
Each bundle is curated to include:
- Coordinated backers
- Properly sized bags
- Matching tags
- Optional add-ons to complete the look
Everything is designed to pair perfectly, so you can assemble quickly and confidently.
We also offer bouquet box bundles, which make it incredibly easy to create those eye-catching cookie bouquets without the extra planning. These are perfect for holidays like Mother’s Day, Teacher Appreciation, and Graduation; high-impact sets that feel premium but are still simple to put together.
Bundles are a huge time-saver during prep. Instead of piecing together supplies for every set, you can streamline your workflow and focus on decorating and fulfilling orders.
And as a bonus, bundles are built with value in mind, so you’re saving money while saving time.
Graduation Cookie Bouquet Bundle
Original price was: $52.50.$47.25Current price is: $47.25.
Teacher Appreciation Cookie Bouquet Bundle
Original price was: $58.50.$52.65Current price is: $52.65.
Mother’s Day Cookie Bouquet Bundle
Original price was: $52.50.$47.25Current price is: $47.25.
Nurse Appreciation Tall Backer Bundle
Original price was: $55.71.$50.14Current price is: $50.14.
Graduation Tall Backer Bundle
Original price was: $56.46.$50.81Current price is: $50.81.
Mother’s Day Tall Backer Bundle
Original price was: $56.46.$50.81Current price is: $50.81.
Everyday Tall Backer Bundle
Original price was: $48.71.$43.84Current price is: $43.84.Die Cut Cookie Cards
If you’re looking for a fast, low-effort product that still feels thoughtful, our die cut cookie cards are a perfect option.
These are designed to make assembly quick and simple; just bag your 2" mini cookie in a 3" x 4" heat seal bag, attach it to the cookie card, and you're ready to sell!
We added 5 new styles for:
They’re perfect for market tables, last-minute shoppers, and lower price point options that will stand out.
These are great for batching, easy to display, and give your customers a grab-and-go option that still feels special.
Cake Pop Cards
Our cake pop cards have quickly become a customer favorite, and for good reason. They’re one of the easiest ways to expand your offerings without adding complexity to your process.
After selling out our Easter styles twice, we introduced 7 new designs for:
They’re fast to assemble, easy to display, and a great way to diversify your menu without taking on extra work.
You’re Ready for Spring!
This time of year moves fast, but with the right tools and products, it doesn’t have to feel overwhelming.
By incorporating simple decorating options like stencils, streamlined packaging, and ready-to-go bundles, you can create beautiful, sellable treats without overcomplicating your process.
Whether you’re focusing on Mother’s Day, Teacher Appreciation, Nurse Appreciation, or Graduation, having a mix of quick options and elevated packaging makes it easier to meet demand while still protecting your time and energy.
Our goal with these spring releases is to help you work smarter, stay organized, and keep your offerings both efficient and profitable.
You’ve got everything you need to take on the season, now it’s time to get baking!
P.S.
I’m sure you’ve seen us mention our Facebook group, and we’re officially over halfway to our 5,000 member goal!
We know how much everyone loves a good celebration, and we have something big planned for when we hit that milestone… but it will be exclusive to our group members.
Our group already gets:
- Early access to new releases
- Exclusive coupon codes
- Sneak peeks at what’s coming next
- And access to an incredibly supportive community of bakers always ready to share tips and help answer questions
If you haven’t joined yet, now’s the time. Help us reach our goal and be part of the celebration, you won’t want to miss it!
